Effectiveness of different irrigant activation techniques in removing smear layer: a scanning electron microscope study
Main Article Content
Abstract
Background: This study evaluated the effectiveness of Laser-Activated Irrigation (LAI), XP-Endo Finisher, and Endo Activator in removing the smear layer from root canal walls by assessing dentinal tubule opening in the coronal, middle, and apical thirds using scanning electron microscopy. Materials and Methods: Thirty single-rooted human anterior teeth were decoronated to a standardized length and prepared using the WaveOne Gold primary rotary system. The samples were randomly divided into three experimental groups (n=10): LAI, XP-Endo Finisher, and Endo Activator, along with a control group irrigated using a conventional syringe technique. The roots were split longitudinally and examined under SEM at 1000x magnification. Images were obtained from the coronal, middle, and apical thirds. Data were analyzed using the Kruskal–Wallis test, with statistical significance set at p<0.05. Results: No statistically significant differences were observed among the three experimental groups in any root third. However, all experimental groups showed significantly better smear layer removal compared with the control group. LAI demonstrated minimal smear layer and greater dentinal tubule openness in the coronal and middle thirds, although remnants persisted apically. The XP-Endo Finisher showed superior performance in the apical third, producing a thinner smear layer. The Endo Activator was most effective in the middle third but left substantial smear layer coverage apically. Complete smear layer removal in the apical third was not achieved by any method. Conclusions: XP-Endo Finisher was most effective apically; Endo Activator in the middle third; and LAI coronally. Utilizing advanced and varied techniques improves smear removal over conventional irrigation.
Received date: 05-01-2025
Accepted date: 22-03-2025
Published date: 15-03-2026
Downloads
Article Details
Issue
Section
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
Licenses and Copyright
The following policy applies in The Journal of Baghdad College of Dentistry (JBCD):
# JBCD applies the Creative Commons Attribution (CC BY) license to articles and other works we publish. If you submit your paper for publication by JBCD, you agree to have the CC BY license applied to your work. Under this Open Access license, you as the author agree that anyone can reuse your article in whole or part for any purpose, for free, even for commercial purposes. Anyone may copy, distribute, or reuse the content as long as the author and original source are properly cited. This facilitates freedom in re-use and also ensures that JBCD content can be mined without barriers for the needs of research.
# If your manuscript contains content such as photos, images, figures, tables, audio files, videos, etc., that you or your co-authors do not own, we will require you to provide us with proof that the owner of that content (a) has given you written permission to use it, and (b) has approved of the CC BY license being applied to their content. We provide a form you can use to ask for and obtain permission from the owner. If you do not have owner permission, we will ask you to remove that content and/or replace it with other content that you own or have such permission to use.Don't assume that you can use any content you find on the Internet, or that the content is fair game just because it isn't clear who the owner is or what license applies.
# Many authors assume that if they previously published a paper through another publisher, they own the rights to that content and they can freely use that content in their paper, but that’s not necessarily the case, it depends on the license that covers the other paper. Some publishers allow free and unrestricted re-use of article content they own, such as under the CC BY license. Other publishers use licenses that allow re-use only if the same license is applied by the person or publisher re-using the content. If the paper was published under a CC BY license or another license that allows free and unrestricted use, you may use the content in your JBCD paper provided that you give proper attribution, as explained above.If the content was published under a more restrictive license, you must ascertain what rights you have under that license. At a minimum, review the license to make sure you can use the content. Contact that JBCD if you have any questions about the license. If the license does not permit you to use the content in a paper that will be covered by an unrestricted license, you must obtain written permission from the publisher to use the content in your JBCD paper. Please do not include any content in your JBCD paper which you do not have rights to use, and always give proper attribution.
# If any relevant accompanying data is submitted to repositories with stated licensing policies, the policies should not be more restrictive than CC BY.
# JBCD reserves the right to remove any photos, captures, images, figures, tables, illustrations, audio and video files, and the like, from any paper, whether before or after publication, if we have reason to believe that the content was included in your paper without permission from the owner of the content.
How to Cite
References
Zehnder M. Root canal irrigants. J Endod. 2006;32:389–398.
Alghamdi F, Shakir M. The influence of Enterococcus faecalis as a dental root canal pathogen on endodontic treatment: a systematic review. Cureus, 2020 Mar 13. 12(3):e7257.
A Mader CL, Baumgartner JC, Peters DD. Scanning electron microscopic investigation of the smeared layer on root canal walls. J Endod. (1984) 10:477–83.
Van der Sluis LW, Versluis M, Wu MK, Wesselink PR. Passive ultrasonic irrigation of the root canal: a review of the literature. Int Endod J. 2007 Jun; 40(6):415-26.
Crumpton BJ, Goodell GG, McClanaban SB. Effects on smear layer and debris removal with varying volumes of 17% REDTA after rotary instrumentation. J Endod. 2005; 31:536–8.
Baumgartner JC, Mader CL. A scanning electron microscopic evaluation of four root canal irrigation regimens. J Endod. 1987;13:147–57.
Teixeira CS, Felippe MC, Felippe WT. The effect of application time of EDTA and NaOCl on intracanal smear layer removal: An SEM analysis. Int Endod J. 2005;38:285–90.
Khedmat S, Shokouhinejad N. Comparison of the efficacy of the three chelating agents in smear layer removal. J Endod. 2008;34:599–602.
Senia ES, Marshall FJ, Rosen S. The solvent action of sodium hypochlorite on pulp tissue of extracted teeth. Oral Surg Oral Med Oral Pathol. 1971;31:96–103,
Baker NA, Eleazer PD, Averbach RE, Seltzer S. Scanning electron microscopic study of the efficacy of various irrigating solutions. J Endod. 1975;1:127–35.
Koçak S, Bağcı N, Çiçek E, Türker SA, Can Sağlam B, Koçak MM. Influence of passive ultrasonic irrigation on the efficiency of various irrigation solutions in removing smear layer: a scanning electron microscope study. Microsc Res Tech. 2017;80:537–542.
Cunningham WT, Balekjian AY. Effect of temperature on collagen-dissolving ability of sodium hypochlorite endodontic irrigant. Oral Surg Oral Med Oral Pathol. 1980;49:175–177.
de Hemptinne F, Slaus G, Vandendael M, Jacquet W, De Moor RJ, Bottenberg P. In vivo intracanal temperature evolution during endodontic treatment after the injection of room temperature or preheated sodium hypochlorite. J Endod. 2015;41:1112–1115.
Iandolo A, Amato M, Dagna A, Poggio C, Abdellatif D, Franco V, et al. Intracanal heating of sodium hypochlorite: Scanning electron microscope evaluation of root canal walls. J Conserv Dent. 2018 Sep-Oct;21(5):569-573.
Blanken JW, Verdaasdonk RM. Cavitation as a working mechanism of the Er, Cr:YSGG laser in endodontics: a visualization study. Open J Stomatol, 2012:2:286-291.
George R, Meyers IA, Walsh LJ. Laser activation of endodontic irrigants with improved conical laser fiber tips for removing smear layer in the apical third of the root canal. J Endod. 2008;34:1524–1527
Lloyd A, Uhles JP, Clement DJ, Garcia-Godoy F. Elimination of intracanal tissue and debris through a novel laser-activated system assessed using high-resolution micro-computed tomography: a pilot study. J Endod. 2014;40:584–587
de Groot SD, Verhaagen B, Versluis M, Wu MK, Wesselink PR, van der Sluis LW. Laser-activated irrigation within root canals: cleaning efficacy and flow visualization. Int Endod J. 2009;42:1077–1083
Blanken J, De Moor RJ, Meire M, Verdaasdonk R. Laser induced explosive vapor and cavitation resulting in effective irrigation of the root canal. Part 1: a visualization study. Lasers Surg Med. 2009;41:514–519
Simeone M, Valletta A, Giudice A, Di Lorenzo P, Iandolo A The activation of irrigation solutions in Endodontics: a perfected technique. Ital Endod. 2015;29:65–69.
Alves FR, Marceliano-Alves MF, Sousa JC, Silveira SB, Provenzano JC, Siqueira JF. Removal of root fillings in curved canals using either reciprocanting single-or rotary multi-instrument systems and a supplementary step with the XP-endo finisher. J Endod. 2016; 42: 1114–1119.
Shalan LA, Al-Huwaizi HF. Cleaning Efficiency of Root Canal after Irrigation with New Irrigation Technique: A Scanning Electron Microscopic Study. Iran Endod J. 2018 Winter;13(1):102-107.
Ulusoy OI, Savur IG, Alacam T, Celik B. The effectiveness of various irrigation protocols on organic tissue removal from simulated internal resorption defects. Int Endod J. 2018; 51: 1030–1036.
Pacheco-Yanes J, Provenzano JC, Marceliano-Alves MF, Gazzaneo I, Perez AR, Goncalves LS, et al. Distribution of sodium hypochlorite throughout the mesial root canal system of mandibular molars after adjunctive irrigant activation procedures: a micro-computed tomographic study. Clin Oral Investig. 2020; 24: 907–914
Haupt F., Meinel M., Gunawardana A., Hulsmann M. Effectiveness of different activated irrigation techniques on debris and smear layer removal from curved root canals: A SEM evaluation. Aust. Endod. J. 2019;46:40–46.
Zhu L, Tolba M, Arola D, Salloum M, Meza F. Evaluation of effectiveness of Er,Cr:YSGG laser for root canal disinfection: theo-retical simulation of temperature elevations in root dentin. J Biomech Eng. 2009 Jul;131(7):071004.
Martins MR, Carvalho MF, Vaz IP, Capelas JA, Martins MA, Gutknecht N. Efficacy of Er,Cr:YSGG laser with endodontical radial firing tips on the outcome of endodontic treatment: blind randomized controlled clinical trial with six-month evaluation. Lasers Med Sci. 2013 Jul;28(4):1049-55.
Caron G, Nham K, Bronnec F, Machtou P. Effectiveness of different final irrigant activation protocols on smear layer removal in curved canals. J Endod. 2010;36(08):1361–1366
Steel B. Lingual Split Versus Surgical Bur Technique in the Extraction of Impacted Mandibular Third Molars: A Systemic Review. Oral Surg Oral Med Oral Pathol Oral Radiol. 2012;114:294.
Azimian S, Bakhtiar H, Azimi S, Esnaashari E. In vitro effect of XP-Endo Finisher on the amount of residual debris and smear layer on the root canal walls. Dent Res J. 2019; 16: 179–184.
Takeda FH, Harashima T, Kimura Y, Matsumoto K. A comparative study of the removal of smear layer by three endodontic irrigants and two types of laser. Int Endod J. 1999;32:32–39.
Armengol V, Jean A, Marion D. Temperature rise during Er: YAG and Nd: YAG laser ablation of dentin. J Endod. 2000;26:138–41.
FKG Dentaire SA. The XP-endo finisher file brochure. Dec 16, 2021.
Elnaghy AM, Mandorah A, Elsaka SE. Effectiveness of XP-endo finisher, EndoActivator, and file agitation on debris and smear layer removal in curved root canals: A comparative study. Odontology. 2017;105:178–83.
Nasab Mobarakeh NM, Taheri A, Rahmanian H, Jafarpour D, Rahmanian S. Effect of various irrigating devices on the removal of two different forms of calcium hydroxide from internal resorption cavities. Int J Dent, 2020 Sep 12:2020:8881177.
Parikh M, Kishan KV, Solanki NP, Parikh M, Savaliya K, Bindu VH, et al. Efficacy of removal of calcium hydroxide medicament from root canals by endoactivator and endovac irrigation techniques: a Systematic review of in vitro studies. Contemp Clin Dent. 2019;10(1):135.
Ali A, Bhosale A, Pawar S, Kakti A, Bichpuriya A, Agwan MA. Current trends in root canal irrigation. Cureus. 2022 May 8:14(5):e24833.
Adham AH, Ali AH, Mannocci F. Continuous Chelation Concept in Endodontics. J Bagh Coll Dent [Internet]. 2022 Dec. 15 ;34(4):59-6.
Versiani MA, Carvalho KKT, Mazzi-Chaves JF, Sousa-Neto MD. Micro-computed tomographic evaluation of the shaping ability of XP-endo Shaper, iRaCe, and EdgeFile systems in long oval-shaped canals. J. Endod. 2018;44:489–495.
Miguéns-Vila R, Martín-Biedma B, Aboy-Pazos S, Uroz-Torres D, Álvarez-Nóvoa P, Dablanca-Blanco AB, et al. Effectiveness of Different Irrigant Activation Systems on Smear Layer Removal: A Scanning Electron Microscopic Study. J Clin Med. 2022 Feb 15;11(4):1003.